Want to know why your billing company might be costing you thousands of dollars each month? The signs are hiding in plain sight.
Not long ago, physical therapy billing was fairly simple. You sent in paper claims and eventually got paid something close to what you billed. It took a while, but you rarely had to fight for it. Today, PT billing is a highly specialized discipline. Getting paid correctly, completely and quickly requires deep knowledge of the industry, a solid grasp of payer policies and access to the best billing platforms available. Without excellence in this area, many clinics barely turn a profit.
The challenge is that billing problems are harder to spot than problems in other parts of your practice. If your marketing stops working, you see it quickly because new patient numbers drop. With billing, it is much harder to tell how good a job is really being done, whether your billing is handled in-house or by an outside company.
Here are five warning signs that your billing company may be underperforming, plus a bonus sign that might surprise you.
Sign #1: Your Income Is Trending Down
Yes, reimbursement has declined, but not dramatically. With Medicare, we are talking about a couple of percentage points. That adds up over time, and the PTA CQ differential has made a real difference. Beyond that, though, if your revenue is dropping significantly while your visit volume stays roughly the same, treat it as a warning sign.
Other factors can lower income per visit:
- Lower-paying plans. In some regions, patients have moved to lower-paying plans. Those plans may not pay less than before, but they now make up a larger share of the market and of your schedule.
- Payer policy changes. Some insurers have made significant adjustments that reduce payments.
- More hoops to jump through. Many insurance companies require a long list of steps before they pay. If those steps are not completed successfully, denials go up.
That is why it is so important to track denials and make sure they are being resolved. Overall, if you are being paid less per visit this year than last, take a closer look at your billing company’s performance.
Sign #2: It Is Taking Longer to Get Paid
With profit margins narrower than they used to be, slow payments hurt more. You may find payroll harder to meet or start delaying other monthly expenses.
If claims are taking longer than 30 to 45 days to be paid, it could point to inefficiencies in claim submission, follow-up or denial management. Many insurers will use any reason they can find to avoid paying you or to pay you less, so your billing team needs to be working every unpaid account frequently and pushing back on those tactics.
Key numbers to watch:
- AR over 90 days: A high percentage of claims sitting here is a major concern.
- AR over 120 days: This should be 10% or less of your total accounts receivable.
- ARC ratio: Divide your total AR by your last three months of charges. The result should be below 0.8, and possibly below 0.5 if your payer mix is less diverse.
If your ARC ratio is above 0.8, it is probably time to get outside expert advice. We would be happy to analyze it for you.
Sign #3: High Claim Denial and Rejection Rates
If you are fairly hands-off with billing, you may not know how many claims are being rejected or denied, but you will likely feel it in the speed and size of your payments.
Frequent denials and rejections can indicate poor coding, missing eligibility verification or a failure to submit clean claims. If your billing company is not proactively addressing denials, it is costing your clinic revenue.
Not every cause is your billing company’s fault. Poor insurance eligibility verification, for example, usually starts at the front desk. But your billing company should be telling you about these problems and giving you strategies to reduce them. If you are not measuring these errors, they are probably costing you a lot of money.
Sign #4: Lack of Transparency and Reporting
A good billing company provides regular, detailed reports on collections, denials and outstanding claims. You should also receive guidance on what is happening with your accounts overall and on any specific issues that are slowing down your payments.
If you are not getting clear insights, or if your billing company avoids discussing performance metrics, they may be hiding inefficiencies. There are a handful of key performance indicators in medical billing. Your billing company should be sharing how your account performs on each of them and explaining any shortfalls.
Sign #5: Poor Communication and Slow Response Times
When you need answers, you need them fast. You should be able to reach your billing team quickly, and you should have at least two points of contact in case someone is out sick or on vacation.
Ideally, you can pick up the phone and speak with someone. When that is not possible and you have to email or leave a message, you should hear back within an hour or two. If that is not happening, your billing company may be overwhelmed and unable to provide the support you need. Worse, they could be avoiding you because they know their performance is subpar.
If it takes days or weeks to get answers or resolve issues, that is a red flag. A good billing company is proactive, accessible and responsive to your concerns.
Bonus Sign #6: Nobody Is Yelling
This one is a little funny: if your billers are not yelling, they may not be doing everything they can.
Our entire billing team works in one office, and when my door is open, I hear our billers every day talking in raised, frustrated voices. Usually they are on the phone with insurance reps in another country, and they often report hearing chickens in the background. The frustration my team endures to get through to unqualified and uncooperative reps is remarkable, and rarely does a day go by without someone raising their voice at an insurance rep.
Every month, I give an award to a different biller on the team. This month, the Mike Tyson Award went to one of our account managers, Bailey. She has been especially vocal on the phone and seems to enjoy the loud battles it takes to get our clients paid.
If your billing team works in your office and you never hear these stressful exchanges, they may not be giving it their all.
The Bottom Line
If you are seeing any of these warning signs, it is time to take a serious look at your billing processes. Every dollar that goes uncollected is a dollar taken out of your pocket, out of your ability to serve patients and out of your ability to grow your practice, which would lead to more security.
Want to learn exactly how to audit your current billing company’s performance? Check out our next video, where we break down the step-by-step process to evaluate whether your billing team is really performing at the level you need.